What to Do If Your Car Is Stolen: Police, Insurance, DMV

You walk back to your parking spot and your car isn’t there. Your heart drops, your mind races, and the clock starts ticking. In those first few minutes, the right moves can boost your chances of getting your vehicle back and protect you from extra headaches like tickets, identity theft, or claim delays.

This guide gives you a clear, time‑ordered plan you can follow immediately: confirm the car wasn’t towed or borrowed, file a police report, activate any GPS or connected‑car tracking and share it with law enforcement, open your insurance claim, alert the DMV and your lender, safeguard your accounts, and document what was inside the car. If you use a real‑time GPS tracker, we’ll show you how to work with police to speed recovery.

You’ll get step‑by‑step instructions, what to say and what to have on hand, realistic timelines for recovery and payouts, how valuation works (ACV, deductibles, gap insurance), what to do if the car is found, and simple prevention upgrades for next time. First up: quick checks to make sure the vehicle is actually stolen.

Step 1. Verify the car is actually stolen (not towed, borrowed, or repossessed)

Before you decide your car is stolen, spend a minute ruling out common mix‑ups. Many “stolen” cars are actually towed, borrowed, or repossessed. Clearing that up fast prevents a false report and saves time. Retrace your steps and verify the exact spot, time parked, and posted restrictions.

• Tow/impound check: Call local police non‑emergency or city impound; ask if it was towed.
• Borrowed/repo check: Confirm no family, friends, shops, or your lender moved it.

Step 2. Call the police immediately and file a stolen vehicle report

Call police immediately. If theft is in progress or you feel unsafe, dial 911; otherwise use the non‑emergency line or online portal to file a stolen‑vehicle report. Quick reporting improves recovery odds and protects you from liability. Ask them to enter your VIN/plates into the national database (NCIC) and give you the case number. Don’t pursue the car—share any live GPS location with dispatch and follow instructions.

• Vehicle: VIN, license plate, year/make/model/color.
• Last seen: Exact time and location; any direction, broken glass.
• Unique marks: Dents, decals, damage, aftermarket parts.
• Keys: Who had keys; any missing spares.
• Tracking/tech: GPS tracker, connected‑car app, dashcam.
• Contents: High‑value items left in the car.

Step 3. Activate any GPS or connected-car tracker and share live location with police

If you have a connected‑car app or GPS tracker, activate it now and provide law enforcement the live location. Real‑time tracking boosts recovery odds—coordinate only through police and never attempt to retrieve the vehicle yourself.

• Turn on stolen mode: Open your automaker app or tracker and enable “Report Stolen”/theft mode.
• Feed location to dispatch: Provide live coordinates (or map pin) and your police case number.
• Document and relay: Share screenshots, VIN/plate, and keep the app open to relay movements.
• LoJack users: A police report activates Classic LoJack via NCIC; newer LoJack/LoJack Go users should contact the recovery concierge to work directly with police.

Step 4. Contact your auto insurer and open a comprehensive theft claim

Call your auto insurer as soon as you have a police case number. Comprehensive coverage typically handles vehicle theft, but notify your carrier even if you don’t have it to protect yourself from liability. Expect an adjuster to be assigned and note some insurers wait up to 72 hours in case the car is quickly recovered. Ask about rental reimbursement if your policy includes it.

• Have ready: Policy number, police report/case number, VIN/plate, year/make/model/color.
• Details: When/where last seen, who had keys/spares, any GPS location you can share.
• Docs: Lender/lessor info, recent photos, mileage/service, distinguishing features.
• Belongings: List items taken; these usually fall under homeowners or renters insurance.

Step 5. Notify your state DMV to flag the VIN and license plates as stolen

After you’ve filed the police report and opened your claim, contact your state DMV. Ask them to flag your VIN and license plates as stolen. This helps block fraudulent title/registration activity and reduces the chance you’re hit with tolls, tickets, or fees while the thief has the car. Many states let you do this online or by phone—have your case number ready.

• Have ready: VIN, license plate, police case/report number, and your contact info.
• Request a status flag: Ask the DMV to note the vehicle and plates as stolen; confirm whether registration will be suspended/canceled and if prorated refunds apply in your state.
• Stolen plates only: If just the plates are gone, report plate theft and request replacements.
• When recovered: Notify the DMV promptly to remove the stolen flag and restore registration status.

Step 6. Inform your lender or leasing company if the vehicle is financed or leased

If you have a loan or lease, notify the lender/lessor right after calling police and your insurer. They have a security interest in the vehicle and will coordinate payoff with your insurance. Provide your police case number, insurance claim number, VIN, and your adjuster’s contact info. Ask how they handle payments during a theft claim and what to do if the car is recovered.

• Have ready: Account number, VIN/plates, police report number, insurer/adjuster details.
• Request: Current payoff or lease balance, settlement mailing instructions, recovery procedures.
• Gap insurance: If you carry gap, ask how to file it if the settlement won’t cover the balance.

Step 7. List personal items taken and consider a homeowners or renters insurance claim

Auto insurance typically won’t cover personal belongings stolen with the vehicle; those losses are usually covered by homeowners or renters insurance. As you work through what to do if your car is stolen, make a clean inventory of what was inside and decide whether to file a separate claim based on value versus your deductible.

• Itemize and value: List each item, replacement cost, and any serial numbers.
• Gather proof: Receipts, photos, cloud purchase history, card statements, device IMEI/serials.
• Use the police report: Include your case number and details of the theft.
• Check coverage math: Compare loss to your deductible; consider credit card purchase protection.

Step 8. Protect your identity and finances if keys, phone, wallet, or documents were in the car

If sensitive items were in the vehicle, lock down your money and identity now while police handle recovery. Thieves often use cards, IDs, mail, or devices to commit fraud. As you work through what to do if your car is stolen, take these steps in parallel to contain risk and document everything in your case file.

• Lock cards immediately: Use your bank/issuer app to freeze cards, then report them lost/stolen and request replacements.
• Monitor accounts: Set real‑time alerts and review recent transactions; dispute anything suspicious right away.
• Add a fraud alert: Place a free fraud alert with any one credit bureau; it propagates to all three.
• Watch your credit: Check reports for new inquiries/accounts and follow up on anything you don’t recognize.
• Secure devices: Use built‑in tools to locate, lock, or erase your phone; change email/banking passwords and 2FA.
• Keys and home safety: If house/garage keys or address info were in the car, rekey locks and clear garage opener remotes.

Step 9. Spread the word safely and check likely recovery spots (impounds, nearby streets, community tips)

While police and your insurer work the case, widen the search without putting yourself at risk. Many stolen cars are abandoned nearby or end up in impound after recovery. Canvas the area in daylight with a friend, keep notes, and share credible tips with law enforcement—never confront anyone.

• Nearby sweep: Check surrounding streets, lots, and alleys for your plates, unique marks, or fresh glass.
• Impound/tow checks: Call police non‑emergency and local tow yards (or any online impound lookup) to see if it was recovered.
• Community signal: Post in neighborhood apps/groups with plate, make/model/color, unique features, last‑seen time/location, and “call police with sightings.”
• Safety/GPS: If you spot it, don’t engage—call 911. Share any live GPS pings only with police.

Step 10. Keep thorough documentation and communicate regularly with your adjuster and detective

Part of what to do if your car is stolen is keeping a tight paper trail and staying in regular touch with your adjuster and the assigned detective. Build one case file—digital or binder—with every document, photo, and update. Use email for updates to preserve timestamps, respond quickly to requests, and if the vehicle is located at any point, notify both immediately.

• Label everything: Put your police case and insurance claim numbers on all files.
• Track contacts: Log dates, names, numbers/emails, and promised next steps.
• Send required docs promptly: ID, title/registration, recent photos, mileage, keys/spares info.
• Share new leads fast: GPS pings, sightings, fraudulent charges, or recovered items.

Step 11. Understand timelines, valuations, and payouts (ACV, deductibles, gap insurance)

As you work through what to do if your car is stolen, set expectations for timing and money. Insurers often wait briefly to see if the car turns up, and many stolen-vehicle claims resolve in a few weeks to a month or more. State rules govern deadlines, and carriers typically must notify you if it’ll take over 30 days. Fast, complete documentation helps speed things up.

• Claim timing: Many carriers pause initially (often a short window) because most stolen cars are recovered; stay in touch with your adjuster.
• Valuation (ACV): Payout is the vehicle’s actual cash value (its current market value) minus your comprehensive deductible; methods vary by insurer.
• Deductible impact: Your chosen comprehensive deductible is subtracted from the settlement amount.
• Loans/leases: For financed or leased cars, the insurer pays the lender/lessor first; any overage goes to you.
• Gap insurance: If ACV is less than your payoff, gap insurance (if you carry it) can cover the difference; otherwise you’re responsible for the shortfall.

Step 12. If your vehicle is recovered, coordinate next steps with police, insurer, and DMV

When police locate your car, slow down and work the plan. Call the assigned officer and your insurer immediately, provide the exact location, and wait for law enforcement to clear the vehicle. Do not confront anyone or drive it away until police release it; coordinate the next steps through your adjuster.

• Tell your insurer right away: They’ll inspect damage and decide repair vs. total loss. If you already received a payout, the insurer typically owns the vehicle; ask about options if you haven’t used the settlement yet.
• Recover personal property: Any belongings found inside are still yours—document what’s recovered.
• Update the DMV: Ask to remove the stolen flag and restore registration; replace plates if needed.
• Re-secure access: Reprogram keys/fobs and garage openers; consider rekeying locks tied to any lost keys.
• Document condition: Photograph the vehicle and note damage, missing parts, and mileage for your claim file.

Step 13. Prevent future theft with layered security, including a real-time GPS tracker

Thieves target easy wins; layered security makes your car a hard pass. As part of what to do if your car is stolen, finish strong with prevention: combine smart habits, visible deterrents, and a recovery plan anchored by a real‑time GPS tracker police can act on fast.

• Keys/locks: Lock every time, take keys/fobs, install automaker security updates.
• Deterrents: Wheel lock, alarm, immobilizer.
• Real‑time GPS: Discreet LiveViewGPS tracker (5–10‑sec updates, geofences, instant alerts); share location with police.

Wrap up

Car theft is a gut punch, but a calm, ordered response gets results: confirm it’s truly stolen, file the police report, activate any tracker and share live location, open your insurance claim, alert the DMV and lender, protect your identity, and keep tight documentation. Then harden your defenses with layered security and a real‑time GPS plan so you’re ready next time. If you want fast recovery tools and instant alerts that work out of the box, consider a tracker from LiveViewGPS and give police the live data they need to act quickly.

You Are Here: LiveViewGPS Blog » What to Do If Your Car Is Stolen: Police, Insurance, DMV